Vinny Lingham's Blog

The Evolution of Search Affiliates

The final session that I attended at CJU, was by Steve August, Operation VP of Customer Marketing for Brookstone. This was certainly the best session of the entire show, and I actually stopped writing (hence the fact that I didn’t blog it), as I was set on getting a copy of his presentation for this blog. Steve kindly obliged, so I’m posting it here. There is a lot of great stuff in here, so I really advise you to watch it – obviously not as good as being there, but some interesting stuff nevertheless.

What’s interesting to note, is that Brookstone is divesting of Search Affiliates, as they are not seeing enough margin in that business for them. From the many discussions I had at CJU, this is a growing trend and the larger Search Affiliates are reinventing themselves into technology companies (Traffic Strategies was recently acquired by Linkshare), having had many years in which to build technology platforms without the need to go through long sales cycles to close business. This put Search Affiliates way ahead of traditional SEM agencies vis a vis focusing on value and not “bid management” – which drove SEM agency revenues. We also took the business on risk, which gave us the opportunity to experiment at our own expense, and determine what the optimal PPC solution should look like, and not be bogged down by client demands in the interim. The result is Media Manager, a proprietary multi-million keyword management system, that allows customers to target ROI, focus on very detailed business intelligence and growth the revenues by optimizing their campaigns, not just increasing their bids – as most other companies propose – especially since they work on a % of spend model.

The role of networks in this evolution is still up for debate. My view is that larger networks such as CJ, Linkshare, Tradedoubler & Performics will become dis-intermediated if they do not change their business models for larger affiliates. The good news is that many of them are already having this discussion and are very co-operative in evolving their businesses into platforms. In a world of mass supply, aggregators hold much of the value of the long tail. Affiliate networks have an aggregation business model, and therefore the value is really in the long tail that they have – the super affiliates or high volume players will need to be treated differently in order to support the business model evolution. The margins for search affiliates are certainly under threat, and Brookstone is experiencing zero-sum returns – this really means that it’s lose lose for networks and search affiliates if there is no margin left for the merchant – something has to give…

Clicks2Customers realized this shift in the industry a while ago, and has quietly become an in-house solutions company, supporting in-house teams by providing access to tried and tested technology that allows them to manage and optimize their multi-million PPC keyword campaigns with precision ROI management. Our Media Manager platform was build on the back of years of generating revenue for merchants, so unlike many of our competitors – it’s a tried and tested solution that focuses on generating revenue, and not increasing bids or spending more money (as per traditional SEM agencies). We’ve only recently embarked on the change in our business model and we’ll be announcing more details in the weeks to come – for now, it’s only being offered to select partners as we roll out. Our model is still performance based and we only make money for value added to a campaign – not the amount spent. We’re evolving from a Super Affiliate to a world class performance search marketing solutions provider!

If you’d like to be considered for our product roll-out, please fill in the contact form on this site. We’re currently only targeting advertisers with spend levels above $500k/year and the budget to grow aggressively.

More news to follow soon!

CJU Session 2007 : Social Networking and the MySpace phenomenon

MySpace Session

Mark Papia from MySpace presents this session and starts off with a video of people telling us how addicted they are to MySpace.

His presentation is entitled “Never Ending Friending”. This presentation will be available online – I’ll get the link to it later – he is moving to fast to get the content down. I’ll just take some notes.

Ad spending on social networks is expected to reach around $865m in 2007, with MySpace taking up 60% of the revenues. There is a lot of market analysis published at Never Ending Friending .

Mark is basically pitching MySpace and obviously, Social Media in the process. He believes that the viral/word of mouth impact from the advertising campaigns leads to strong ROI, but not directly from the actual campaign itself. I’m skeptical :-)

He is going to Q & A now, time for some grilling…

CJU Session : The Pulse of the Affiliate Market

Rebecca Madiga

Rebecca Madigan from CJ presents this great session.  Unfortunately, I didn’t manage to get to blog the opening sessions – due to not being able to find a place to sit!  The room was packed!

Rebecca conducted interviews with Top Performing Publishers & Advertisers in order to provide content for this session.

Topics Covered:

  • Perspectives
  • Important Issues
  • Suggestions
  • Trends

1/3 international respondents

  •  Average of 10 Weeks to receive commission payment
  •  Up to 50% fees charges
  •  9 more countries added to direct bank transfer payouts

Advertiser Profile:

  • Average time in affiliate marketing : 4.8 years
  • Number of hours a week : 40
  • Percentage of time dedicated to Affiliate: 58%

Publisher Profile:

  • Average time in affiliate marketing : 8.5 years
  • Number of hours a week: 61.5
  •  Average ramp up to full time: 8.5 months
  • Biggest business threats:
    • Disinformation about the affiliate channel
    • Time

Publishers:  Selection criteria when choosing an Advertiser  (in order):

  1. Advertiser Response
  2. Brand
  3. Conversion Rate
  4. Deep Linking
  5. Commission
  6. Consumer Incentive
  7. Keyword Policy
  8. Product Feed
  9. Network
  10. Publisher Incentive

(Advertisers should consider consumer incentives, above publisher incentives for their program).

Advertiser:  Selection criteria when accepting Publishers (in order):

  1.  CJ Performer
  2. Vertical
  3. Geographic Location
  4. ( a few more that went past faster than I could type!!)

It’s very difficult to blog the rest of the session, as the camera man keeps switching my screen over to Rebecca, and not the slideshow!  I’ll try to put some notes down:

On the survey, almost everyone said that both the publisher & the merchant share the consumer.

“The consumer is married to the advertiser, but the publisher is her best friend” – comments from a loyalty site owner.

Partner Tip:

Advertiser :  Ad key target markets and program objectives in your advertiser detail page.   Send your promotional calendar and marketing plan to your top publishers and find mutual opportunities.

What’s next in the Affiliate Sector?

  •  Consolidation:  the big overtaking the small by acquisition or competition
    • Publishers, Advertisers, Networks
  • New tools to make it easier for consumers to choose & buy (e.g. web services), in new places to buy (e.g. Social Networks)
  • Increased demand for measurable results
  • Affiliate sector getting a bigger piece of the marketing pie
  • SEO growth
  • Everyone needs to ‘come clean’
  • Will cookies continue to be viable?
  • Affiliate is just beginning – lets do a better job at it!

CJ Publisher Advisory Board Finalised

I announced late last year that Commission Junction was establishing their Publisher Advisory Board, which was finalised today.

The full members of the board are:

Adam Viener, Imwave, Inc.
Connie Berg, FlamingoWorld.com / iShopDaily.com
Craig Cassata, MrRebates.com
Dan Murray, Ravenwood Marketing
David M. Lewis, 77Blue
Eva Klein, FatWallet
Jennifer Nissenberg, Upromise
Jeremy Palmer, QuitYourDayJob.com
Michael Coley, Amazing-Bargains.com
Paul Nichols, Ebates.com
Scott Jangro, MechMedia, Inc.
Scott Kluth, CouponCabin.com
Steve Schaffer, Vertive, Inc
Vinny Lingham, Clicks2Customers.com

In addition, Kerri Pollard made the following message:

At Commission Junction, we are always looking for ways to develop sustainable relationships and improve our services to our clients in order to drive quality results. Keeping with that tradition, we aspired to enhance the communication channel between Commission Junction and our publishers. As a result, I am proud to introduce our Publisher Advisory Board (PAB).

The objective of the PAB is to help Commission Junction build mutually beneficial solutions for the future. To meet this objective, we have recruited a group of notable, established publishers from within our network to serve as the voice for their community.

Commission Junction will proactively obtain feedback from the PAB regarding successes or opportunities they observe throughout the lifecycle of a business or technical initiative. The PAB will collaborate with the Commission Junction executive board to implement enhancements in order to warrant success for all parties.

I look forward to working with this esteemed group of individuals, and I cannot wait to watch their ideas come to fruition at Commission Junction.

Sincerely,

Kerri Pollard
Vice President, Client Performance
Commission Junction, a division of ValueClick, Inc.

CJU 2006 Session : Web Services

Frank Gerstenberger, Director of Product Management, Commission Junction

Agenda

About Web Services
Commission Junction Web Services
Examples of Working Applications
Working with us
What’s Next

What are Web Services?

Web services can provide the basic building blocks to build simplex, or complex solutions.

It’s possible to create a solution using Web Services from multiple Web Service providers.

Most modern languages support Web services and have specific features to utilize SOAP services

What is the CJ Web Services Vision:

Enable and promote innovation and differentiation in the CJ Marketplace by creating new opportunities for publishers and advertisers.

Create innovative new solutions that drive increased transactions
Enable rich user experiences
Decrease development time
Develop a service based foundation for the future

What problems does it solve?

Example:  Commission Junction Product Catalog

Over 700 advertisers with a product catalog(s)
Over 850 product catalogs
Over 20,000,000 products

Web Services being launched:

Publisher:

Product catalog Search
Advertiser Search
Link Search

Advertisers:

Branded Sign-up
Branded Login
Publisher Lookup

Publisher Web Services:

Frank goes through 3 examples.

Ideas for Web Services:

Innovate & Differentiate
Plug-in for blog software
Widget for a web site
Product search incorporated into coupon site
Browser toolbar
Price comparison site
A new interface for finding information

What’s next?      

Advertiser Signup enhancements
Transactional Reporting Data
Performance Reporting Data
Relationship Management Data

Vinny Lingham is an International Award winning Entrepreneur & Search Engine Marketer. He is currently CEO of Free Website maker, Yola.

Learn more about Vinny »
Recent Categories Archives
View All » View All »
General February 2010
Yola September 2009
Web 2.0 August 2009
Yahoo July 2009
Media Coverage June 2009
Synthasite May 2009
Venture Capital April 2009
Affiliate Marketing March 2009
Conferences February 2009
Startups January 2009